If you tripped over a pallet, a pallet jack, a flatbed stock cart, a box left by a stocker or the low corner of a display in a store aisle in California, the store’s first response will almost always be the same sentence: it was open and obvious, you should have seen it. Adjusters say it, defense lawyers write it, and injured people hear it and assume they have no case. They are wrong more often than not. California law has treated the open-and-obvious argument as a limited defense for decades, and in a store that invites customers to look at shelves rather than at the floor, it is weaker still. Here is what the rule actually says, why stocking hazards are a known problem in retail, and how these cases are proven.
What “open and obvious” actually means in California
The rule comes from a line of Court of Appeal decisions, including Osborn v. Mission Ready Mix in 1990 and Martinez v. Chippewa Enterprises in 2004, and it is written into the jury instruction at CACI 1004. An obvious hazard can relieve an owner of the duty to warn about it, because a warning adds nothing to what the person can already see. It does not relieve the owner of the duty to fix it, or to avoid creating it, when it is foreseeable that people will encounter the hazard anyway because of where it is. A pallet in the middle of a store aisle is the textbook example. The store knows customers will walk down that aisle. It knows they will be reading shelf tags, comparing prices, reaching for products and watching their children, not studying the floor. The foreseeability of someone walking into the pallet is exactly why leaving it there is negligent, obvious or not.
The practical effect is that “open and obvious” in a store case is usually a comparative fault argument, not a complete defense. The store says you share some blame for not seeing it. A jury assigns percentages. Your recovery is reduced by your share, not eliminated, under California’s comparative negligence rule from Li v. Yellow Cab.
Why stocking hazards are a known problem
Every large retailer has written policies about stocking during business hours, because tripping over stocking equipment is one of the most common customer injuries in the industry. The policies typically require that pallets be stocked from the end of an aisle and not left unattended, that an employee stay with a pallet jack, that empty pallets go to the back room immediately, that low pallets be fitted with high-visibility corner guards, that flatbed carts be parked against shelving rather than across the aisle, and that stocking of busy aisles happen overnight or before opening. Many stores also require caution cones or “stocking in progress” signage.
Those policies are the measuring stick. When a store’s own rules say an unattended pallet is not allowed and you tripped over an unattended pallet, the store has violated its own standard of care. The policies are obtained in discovery, along with the training materials, and they are often the most persuasive document in the case.
The low pallet problem
A standard wooden pallet is about five inches high. An empty one, or one with a single layer of product left, sits below a shopper’s natural field of view and is nearly invisible against a grey floor from a few feet away. Its corners extend past whatever is stacked on it. A person stepping around a display or turning out of an aisle catches a foot on the corner and goes down forward, which is why these falls produce broken wrists, shoulder injuries, facial injuries and knee injuries rather than the hip and back injuries of a slip. Retail safety literature has recognized the low pallet problem for years, which is why the corner guards and the attendance rules exist.
How the case is proven
Video. Stores have continuous camera coverage of most aisles and all endcaps. The footage shows how long the pallet sat there, whether an employee was with it, whether cones or guards were used, and how you approached it. It is overwritten on the store’s retention schedule unless a written preservation demand reaches the company quickly, so that letter goes out in the first days.
The incident report. The manager’s report often records who was stocking, what was on the pallet and what was done after the fall. It is written to protect the store, but it fixes facts the store cannot later change.
The store’s policies and training. Obtained in discovery and compared to what happened.
Staffing. Who was assigned to stock that aisle, where they were, and why the pallet was unattended.
Your account and witnesses. What you were doing, where you were looking and why, which in a store is almost always a reasonable answer. Other customers who saw the pallet sitting there are the witnesses the store does not control.
Medical records, from the first visit, describing the mechanism of the fall and every injury.
What to do
Photograph the pallet or cart where it is before it is moved, including its height, its color against the floor, any guards or cones, and the view from the direction you came. Note the time and the aisle. Report it and get the manager’s name. Ask whether an employee was assigned to the pallet. Get witness names. Treat the same day. Do not give a recorded statement to the store’s claims administrator; the “did you see it” question is the whole point of the call.
Key points
Open and obvious in California limits the duty to warn, not the duty to fix or to avoid creating a hazard people will foreseeably walk into. In a store aisle, it is a comparative fault argument, not a bar.
Retailers have written stocking policies: no unattended pallets, corner guards, cones, stocking off-hours. A violation of the store’s own policy is the center of the case.
Low pallets sit below a shopper’s field of view and catch the foot at the corner. The injuries are forward falls: wrists, shoulders, faces, knees.
Video and the stocking schedule prove how long the hazard sat there. Preserve them in writing immediately.
Frequently asked questions
The store says it is my fault because I was looking at the shelf. Is it? Looking at the shelf is what the store built the aisle for. A jury may assign some percentage to you, but California law does not bar the claim.
There was a cone next to the pallet. Does that end it? No. A cone next to a pallet in the middle of a busy aisle may be less than reasonable care when the policy says the pallet should not have been there at all. Where the cone was relative to your approach matters.
It was a vendor’s employee stocking, not the store’s. Who is responsible? Usually both. The store controls the aisle; the vendor controlled the pallet. Both are named and the contracts allocate it between them.
How long do I have? Two years from the fall under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1.
Manoukian Law Firm, P.C., Chatsworth, California. Free consultation. No fee unless we win. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.




