Free consultation · No fee unless we winEspañolՀայերենFree consultation →
, ,

Pedestrian Death on a Los Angeles Street: When the City Is Responsible

When a pedestrian is killed on a Los Angeles street, the driver is the obvious defendant and usually the only one the family hears about. But a significant share of pedestrian deaths in this city happen at locations the City itself has identified as dangerous: wide, fast arterials with long distances between signals, crosswalks the…

A person crossing a busy street lined with palm trees in Hollywood, Los Angeles.

When a pedestrian is killed on a Los Angeles street, the driver is the obvious defendant and usually the only one the family hears about. But a significant share of pedestrian deaths in this city happen at locations the City itself has identified as dangerous: wide, fast arterials with long distances between signals, crosswalks the City removed, intersections with inadequate lighting, and signals timed so that a person cannot cross before the light changes. When the design or condition of the street contributed to the death, the City of Los Angeles can be a defendant, and its liability insurance, or more precisely its self-insurance, is not limited by a private driver’s small policy. The catch is the deadline. A claim against the City must be filed within six months of the death, not two years. Here is when the City is responsible, what the family has to prove, and what has to happen before the six months run.

The driver first

The driver who struck the pedestrian owes the full wrongful death damages under ordinary negligence law: the heirs’ lost financial support, household services, funeral expenses and the loss of love and companionship, as explained in our article on who may file. Vehicle Code section 21950 requires drivers to yield to pedestrians in marked and unmarked crosswalks at intersections, and the basic speed law at section 22350 requires a speed reasonable for conditions, which on a city street at night with pedestrians present is often well below the posted limit. The driver’s liability policy is the first source of recovery, and the decedent’s own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is the second when the driver’s policy is small or the driver fled.

When the City is responsible

Government Code section 835 makes a public entity liable for injury caused by a dangerous condition of its property when the entity created the condition or had notice of it in time to fix it, the condition created a reasonably foreseeable risk of the kind of injury that occurred, and the injury was caused by it. A street is City property. A dangerous condition is one that creates a substantial risk of injury when the property is used with due care in a reasonably foreseeable manner, and the courts have held that the foreseeable negligence of third parties, including speeding drivers, is part of the analysis when the street’s design makes that negligence more likely to kill.

In pedestrian death cases the dangerous conditions that recur are these. Uncontrolled crosswalks on multi-lane arterials where a driver in one lane stops and a driver in the next does not. Crosswalks that the City removed without providing an alternative, leaving a bus stop or a school on one side and the neighborhood on the other. Signal timing that does not give a pedestrian enough time to cross. Missing, damaged or obstructed pedestrian signals and signs. Streetlights out for extended periods on a known high-injury corridor. Sight lines blocked by City-maintained landscaping or parking the City permitted. Intersections with a documented history of pedestrian collisions and no countermeasures.

The City’s own documents prove notice. Los Angeles maintains a High Injury Network, a list of the streets where the most severe and fatal collisions occur, and the Department of Transportation and the Bureau of Engineering keep collision histories, signal timing records, work orders, citizen complaints and the records of what safety projects were proposed and funded for each corridor. Those records are obtained through the Public Records Act and in litigation, and a corridor that appears on the City’s own danger list with no countermeasures installed is the center of the case.

The City’s defenses

Design immunity. Government Code section 830.6 immunizes a public entity for an injury caused by the plan or design of a public improvement when the design was approved in advance by an authorized official and a reasonable official could have approved it. This is the City’s main defense, and it is a real one. It is overcome when the dangerous condition was not part of the approved design, when the design was never actually approved by the right body, when the condition resulted from a failure to maintain rather than from design, or when changed conditions, such as years of collisions after the design was built, gave the City notice that the design had become dangerous and a reasonable time to act. The collision history is what defeats design immunity in most cases.

Notice. The City will say it did not know. Answered by the collision history, complaints, and its own High Injury Network designation.

Third-party fault. The City will say the driver, or the pedestrian, caused the death, not the street. Comparative fault applies, and the City pays its share. A City that is found ten percent at fault for a death pays ten percent of the damages, which, when the driver carried a minimum policy, is often most of the recovery that is actually collectible.

Trivial defect and ordinary risks. Streets have hazards; not every one is actionable. The claim is strongest where the City’s own records show it knew this location was killing people.

The six-month rule

Government Code section 911.2 requires that a claim for death or personal injury against a public entity be presented within six months of the accrual of the cause of action, which in a death case is the date of death. The claim is a written form, filed with the City Clerk, stating the facts, the injury and the amount claimed. The City then has 45 days to act. If it rejects the claim or does nothing, the family has six months from the rejection, or two years from the death if no written rejection is sent, to file suit. Missing the initial six months is nearly always fatal to the claim. A late-claim application is possible within one year for limited reasons, such as the claimant’s minority or incapacity, but the standard is strict and the City opposes them.

The practical consequence: in any pedestrian death on a City street, the family should assume the City may be a defendant until an investigation says otherwise, and the claim should be filed within six months regardless, because the cost of filing a claim that proves unnecessary is nothing, and the cost of not filing one that was necessary is the case. The same rule applies to the County, Caltrans for state highways, and Metro for bus-involved deaths, each with its own claim form.

The evidence

The scene, photographed from the pedestrian’s and the driver’s perspectives, in the same lighting, before anything changes. The City often installs a crosswalk or a signal after a fatality; that fact is not admissible to prove fault, but the before condition must be documented first. The LAPD or CHP collision report and the investigating officer’s measurements. Traffic camera, business and doorbell video. Witnesses. The City’s collision history for the location, its signal timing sheets, its streetlight maintenance records and its complaint file. The coroner’s report. An engineer who specializes in traffic safety and roadway design to analyze whether the location met the standards in the California Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices and whether the City’s own guidelines called for countermeasures.

Key points

A pedestrian death claim runs against the driver first; the City of Los Angeles is a defendant when a dangerous condition of the street, such as an unprotected crosswalk, a removed crosswalk, bad signal timing or lighting, contributed to the death.

Government Code 835 sets the standard. The City’s own High Injury Network and collision records are the proof of notice.

Design immunity under section 830.6 is the City’s main defense; a collision history that gave the City notice the design had become dangerous defeats it.

A government claim must be filed within six months of the death under section 911.2. File it even if the City’s role is uncertain.

Document the scene before the City changes it.

Frequently asked questions

The driver was clearly at fault. Why would the City be involved? Because a driver with a minimum policy cannot pay for a death, and because the City’s share of fault for a street it knew was dangerous is real. Both defendants are pursued; the City is often the only one that can pay.

The City installed a signal at the intersection a month after my father was killed. Can we use that? Not to prove the City was at fault; the law excludes subsequent repairs for that purpose. It can be used for other purposes, including to show the City controlled the location and that a fix was feasible. More important is to document what the intersection looked like before the change.

We are past six months. Is there anything left? A late-claim application may be possible within one year for limited reasons. The claim against the driver is unaffected and runs for two years. Get advice immediately.

Is a crash on a state highway or near a freeway ramp the City or the State? Caltrans controls state highways, including some major surface streets, and freeway ramps. The claim form and the agency differ; the six-month deadline is the same.

Manoukian Law Firm, P.C., Chatsworth, California. Free consultation. No fee unless we win. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Last reviewed by Vaheh Manoukian, Esq., founding attorney, Manoukian Law Firm.

Client reviews

What clients say

★★★★★

From the moment I reached out, Vaheh was responsive, professional, and attentive to my needs. He took the time to carefully explain all my options, answered all of my questions, and made sure I felt comfortable throughout the entire process.

Erik S. · Google review
★★★★★

His work ethic, integrity, and attention to detail are unmatched. Vaheh communicates clearly, keeps you informed, and makes you feel supported every step of the way. It's rare to find an attorney who combines skill, compassion, and professionalism at this level.

Serj A. · Google review
★★★★★

He handled my car accident case and was extremely responsive and helpful during the entire process. He took the time to explain everything.

Axel M. · Google review
★★★★★

Helped me maneuver through everything in a timely manner. Easy to get a hold of and is very communicative.

Brittany K. · Google review

Reviews are from Google and are reproduced as written. Every case is different, and results vary.

Read more reviews →

Free consultation

Start with a free consultation.

Confidential and free, with no obligation. Tell us what happened, and an attorney calls you back the same business day.

(818) 818-5031

Tell us what happened.

Free and confidential. An attorney calls you back the same business day.

or
Pick a time for a call back By submitting you agree to be contacted about your case by phone, text or email. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out. See our Privacy Policy and Terms. Protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.